Has George Orwell's rules stood the test of time?
Has George Orwell's rules stood the test of time?
In the 1940's George Orwell created an essay stating that the English language was devolving. In that essay he stated a set of rules that someone would have to follow to use the English Language effectively. These rules can be seen bellow
1. Never use a metaphor, simile, or other figure of speech which you are used to seeing
in print.
2. Never use a long word where a short one will do.
3. If it is possible to cut a word out, always cut it out.
4. Never use the passive where you can use the active.
5. Never use a foreign phrase, a scientific word, or a jargon word if you can think of an
everyday English equivalent.
6. Break any of these rules sooner than say anything outright barbarous.
These rules could be summed up to not using common metaphors, simplify your language as much as possible and to only break or bend these rules slightly as possible or if you're sounding too much like a child writing an essay.
Now, do the rules that Orwell had presented still hold up today? Do they still make an effective use of the English language? Yes and no. Orwell's rules are effective if someone wishes to push their agenda, being as upfront as possible to make as many people understand your point of view and to get them to your side. Breaking these rules could also be useful to your agenda, but only if talking about an apposing idea or agenda. An example of someone using Orwell's rules while simultaneously breaking them to push their agenda would be Trump.
The current President of the United states, Donald Trump, recently gave a speech addressing the environment, pollution and carbon emissions in the United States. Trump, in previous campaign speeches, stated, quite verbally, his views on climate change, his belief that it is all just a hoax. In the most recent speech he gave addressing the environment he dances around the subject of climate change, never even stating the phrase "climate change" or addressing it effect on the environment, only pollution in the breathing air and drinking water. Trump uses Orwell's rules of being as direct as possible when it comes to his agenda on climate change, that it's a hoax and that China is somehow profiting off of it but when his agenda is challenged or he has to talk about an opposing idea he breaks the rules to make the opposing argument sound not as important or give little value as possible to the argument.
In the end, Orwell's rules are extremely effective when it comes to fighting for your Agenda but also fighting against opposing Agendas. These rules are used to be as direct as possible and to get as many people on your side and breaking these rules to give as little value, attention or even credibility to the opposing side. Orwell's rules, if used correctly could use all of the three proofs effectively, sounding intellectual and credible while its direct nature could invoke strong emotions to its audience while simultaneously breaking these rules to make the opposing arguments sound credible and not even create a strong emotional connection. Use the rules when they fit your agenda, break them if they don't.
Comments
Post a Comment